|
|
|
|
|
Asked by Unregistered on Sun 09, Mar 2008 04:47am :
|
|
I had an abnormal pap smear eight years ago, i ended up having to have a cone biopsy "leep procedure" done. i had
normal pap's for over 7 years now. a couple months ago i had another pap done and it came back abnormal again, my doctor
said to come back in a few months to see if the abnormalty went away or not. i decided not to go back. am i at any danger of
this getting worse? i was told that after five years of normal pap's then i had nothing to worry about, it's been 7
years and now it's abnormal again. I've also had several surgeries to remove endometriosis, would that be the cause
of the abnormalties? I just have so much scare tissue that i have pain in my pelvis and stomach all the time and would love
to avoid any more surgeries if possible. please let me know if this can be avoided or not. I also have a family history of
cancer, i don't know if that would matter or not. thanks for any information.
|
|
|
|
|
Answer by Dr Heinrik M, MD (doctor) on Mon 10, Mar 2008 08:19am:
Hi,
The screening for cervical cancer could reduce your risk for getting invasive cervical cancer from 24 to 70%
and reduce risk of death by 22%.
If you decide to forego the tests, you will lose this advantage.
These numbers are a bit hard to imagine. If we consider US data, for a total population of 304 million,
assuming half are women that would be about 152 Million women at risk for cervical cancer. About 11000 are
estimated to be diagnosed in 2007. This would mean a risk of 1 for every 13800 women. With screening, you
could belong in a risk group with odds of 1 for every 48000 women. It confers about a 1 to 3 fold reduction.
This may seem modest, however as a whole screening has led to a 70% decline in mortality since the 1940s.
Endometriosis has no clear relationship to cervical cancer, but I do understand that this is a factor in your
decision making due to the symptoms that this condition and/or its treatment. Family history is also not an
issue. The sexual history is.
I think you need to explore what elements of the screening you do not like. If it is a matter of
discomfort/pain associated with the procedure – you may consider taking some pain medications around the time
of the procedure. If it is the frequency of having it done per year, you could explore a liquid-based cytology
which would make the interval 2 years.
However, what is crucial now is that there is an abnormal preliminary finding. While there is indeed a high
false positive rate with current screening (going back to the 11000 who will be diagnosed, there are about 2
to 3 million women would have further evaluation), your risk now increases from the baseline risk of 1 in
13800 women to 1 in 180 women. I think an evaluation is better than no evaluation, even if it seems the
abnormality has a good spontaneous resolution rate (since the doctor was willing to observe its course). There
is no reason to believe, that the history of 7 years normal Pap will guarantee another normal finding although
the chances are in favor of a normal finding.
You could also discuss cervical cancer vaccines and how they may afford some added protection. The final
analysis regarding its use in a therapeutic rather than a prophylactic setting is promising but is yet to be
completed.
|
|
|
Please rate my answer (select the stars below, no need to log in.)
|
|
|
|
|
Other medical questions you might be interested in. Please rate doctor’s answers.
|
- B
one tumor - MRI revealed bone tumor, bone cyst, bursitis, effusion possibly aneurysmal bone
cyst (Answered)
- Viewed 640 times
I fell and have had lots of pain, so the ER ordered an MRI shows that It showed a bone tumor, bone cyst,
bursitis, effusion pos...
- Confusing
Symptoms - Experiencing a constant feeling of fullness or bloating (Answered)
- Viewed 1357 times
Should I see a doctor regarding the following symptoms… I have recently been experiencing a constant feeling
of fullness or blo...
- i got a liver cyst - is
liver cyst dangerous can it form into cancer (Answered)
- Viewed 343 times
is liver cyst dangerous can it form into cancer What are my treatment options for …? What
experimental drug ...
- Ovarian cancer - Bloated
and thoracic back pain with pain in pelvis (Answered)
- Viewed 1822 times
I am 22 years old and on birth control. I have had abnormal pap smears for the past 3 years and have had a
cervical coloscopy tw...
- Results - Neck ultrasounds show several cervical lymph nodes and CT Scan reveals high to mid level internal
jugular chain position (pending)
- Viewed 2829 times
2 neck Ultrasounds showed several cervical lymph nodes (2.7 cm by 1 cm) Follow up CT Scan Finding: There is
a 6mm node in the ...
- possibility of MM? (Answered)
- Viewed 197 times
I had a cbc done on 02/11/08 because of a tooth infection and a bad cold. ( I had a root canal done the
following week). On 3/16...
- Experiencing heart flutters,
dizziness, and vision impairment (Answered)
- Viewed 2657 times
This morning I experienced a moderate headache with some nausea. Then I began experiencing impaired vision
where it started wit...
- Serum Immunofixation test result - What does IgG Kappa monoclonal protein detected in serum immunofixation
test mean? (Answered)
- Viewed 1900 times
What does IgG Kappa monoclonal protein detected in serum immunofixation test mean? This is a follow up test
for the protein elec...
- Womens Health problem! - White /
yellow smelly discharge. (Answered)
- Viewed 6484 times
I have missed a period, taken three pregnancy tests, all were negative. I have always been regular with my
periods, im very worr...
- Blurry vision followed by arm numbness on one of the arms and then sever headache for about 24 hours. 2
tylenols and sleep would not take it away. (Answered)
- Viewed 1388 times
Hello, I am a male in my mid twenties. I would like to find out what the problem is with my body. I get arm
numbness once in a ...
- vaginaa friend of mind went to a doctor and she was complainting about white growth on the outside of the
opening of her vagina, she didn't have a pap smear perform can you tell by the physical eye what it can be?
can you diagnose a person by looking at t (Answered)
- Viewed 501 times
a friend of mind went to a doctor and she was complainting about white growth on the outside of the opening of
her vagina, she d...
- Enlarged Right Kidney,
Atrophied Left Kidney Severe pain in left side (Answered)
- Viewed 1820 times
I have an enlarged Right Kidney, Atrophied(very small) left Kidney. Pain in left side above bellybutton, below
breast 2"-3", on ...
- I have seen multiple specialists for a sudden episode of wheezing/upper respiratory symptoms & no firm
diagnosis. Please help. (Answered)
- Viewed 564 times
18 months ago, i suddenly developed wheezing, moderate shortness of breath, severe tightness all on the left
lung & chest. After...
- Enlarged ovary, Fibroids in uterus, and Implanon, all of these are playing a role in stomach pains and
discomfort. (pending)
- Viewed 3227 times
Last Tuesday I went to the emergency room for sharp pains in my lower right abdomen and vomiting, shakes and
sweats. Appendicit...
- Concerned with my menstral cycle which is 15 days late now. Pregnancy tests results were negative, what do I
do.. (Answered)
- Viewed 1065 times
My mentral cycles usually varies between 28-31 days. The only time it was regulated was on the pill. I have
had endometriosis ...
- Brown vaginal
Discharge (low iron, last pregnancy delivery was a c-section) (Answered)
- Viewed 5534 times
Hi, My question is I have a brown discharge which followed after my monthly cycle (I'm currently taking iron
pills) nothing that...
- shaky vision and
migraines with numbness of my hands and inability to focus (Answered)
- Viewed 200 times
i have been having shaking vision, almost like im looking out a kaleidescope, having problems focusing,
followed by sudden migra...
- weight gain chronic nausea
vitamin c d k deficiencies lethargy (Answered)
- Viewed 217 times
I had gastric by pass roux en y about 4 years ago. I was alrmed at my newest blood results and am stumped as
to why I have the ...
- Intermittent
stomach pain, diarrhea and vomiting with mostly low-grade fever for a week (Answered)
- Viewed 5749 times
I am a 74 year old female with intermittent diarrhea with very painful cramps. I am learning to live with it,
however, in the p...
- Recurring bladder
infections apparently associated with sexuall activity (Answered)
- Viewed 182 times
My wife and I have been married for over 29 years. In the last 2 years it seems that within a few days of
having sex, she develo...
|
Visitors to this page searched for:
diarrhea and abnormal pap smear:1 visits 0 bounces 216 secs spent on page; line running down stomach:0
visits 0 bounces 86
secs spent on page; cerebellar tonsils low lying:0 visits 0 bounces 84 secs spent on page; kicking movements
in stomach not
pregnant:0 visits 0 bounces 82 secs spent on page; had irregular smear 7 years ago:1 visits 0 bounces 77 secs
spent on page;
assisting with a pap smear:0 visits 0 bounces 7 secs spent on page; 3 bad pap smears:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs
spent on page;
abnormal pap smear and late period:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; abnormal pap smear and leg pain:1
visits 1
bounces 0 secs spent on page; abnormal pap smear and yellow/brown discharge:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on
page; abnormal
smear 3 missed periods back pain:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; after having an abnormal pap test
what do i expect
next iam 74 yrs. old female:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; always have had normal pap test now
abnormal:1 visits 1
bounces 0 secs spent on page; am i taking a risk if i dont follow up after an abnormal pap?:1 visits 1 bounces
0 secs spent
on page; can a uti cause a pap to be abnormal:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; coloscopy scar tissue
discharge:1
visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; dizziness and an abnormal pap:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page;
gastric bypass
and abnormal pap smear:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; had an abnormal pap 4 yrs ago do i have cancer
now:1 visits 1
bounces 0 secs spent on page; had an abortion now pap is abnormal:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; i
had an abnormal
pap smear and didn't follow up:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; last smear 7 years ago:1 visits 1
bounces 0 secs
spent on page; low back pain and abnormal pap smear:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; my wife pap smear
white
discharge:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; normal pap test for 7 yrs now have an abnormal one:1 visits
1 bounces 0
secs spent on page; painful abdomen and abnormal pap:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; swollen left
kidney and
abnormal smear results:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; what if i had a pap test and it came back
abnormal and
positive for chlamidia?:1 visits 1 bounces 0 secs spent on page; white discharge abnormal pap:1 visits 1
bounces 0 secs spent
on page; |
|